Before this season I hadn't watched
American Idol in seven years. Megan and I watched it in 2005 and 2006. We watched every show, and it was a great reason to drink during the week. We actually used to call in votes for contestants back then. You're welcome Taylor Hicks. Also, Hr. Hicks, if you're wondering who bought the one album you sold, it was Megan. I'm sure you remember it was sold in a Best Buy in Minnetonka. We used to live in St. Louis Park, see?
I'm surprised the show is still chugging along. I know Harry Connick Jr. is a judge now, and I don't know who the other two are, but sometimes this season I'll flip it on as I fold laundry, or feed Ozzie. Randy Jackson is still running around on there, but he's not a judge anymore. I've seriously only seen about 23 minutes total of this season, but from what I've seen, they have kept up with the times pretty well.
It looks like you can vote for contestants up to 50 times now from your phone, Facebook, or Twitter. That's pretty cool. Also it looks like you can vote during the show, and they have up date reports of who is where in the live voting. Then on the results show they flash Facebook pictures of the people who voted for the person they're talking about. In my drunken days I'd have been obsessed with having my picture flashed on screen. (Who am I kidding? If I watched this year, I'd be obsessed with it now)
I've been underwhelmed by the singing I've seen from the contestants. Mind you, I've only seen about three of the top 12 sing, but they miss notes, and after the performance the judges don't call them on it. I was a production assistant for
The Voice when they had a cattle call come through here, and the singers who made it passed the cattle call were all excellent.
I worked the cattle call at the River Centre in St. Paul. I got to work in "the yes room." It was where the contestants who the judges put through went to sign the necessary paperwork to advance to more auditions. It was awesome being in that room all day. Everyone who came in the room was having the best day of their lives. They'd waited in line for hours, made it to the judges, and then made it to call backs. Parents of minors were beaming with pride, calling the other parent (in Iowa, or Wisconsin, or Michigan!) with the good news that they had to stay in town until the call back on Wednesday. American Idol season five-4th runner up Paris Bennett came through the room. I watched that season and recognized her. That was cool. She was really shy.
I also worked two of the three call backs days. Day three would have been the call backs from the cattle call, but the people I heard were singers who show researchers found in and near Minnesota with websites of their music. I sat on the other side of the door of the audition room. Other P.A.'s would send singers to me and we'd wait for the person in the room to finish before the next one could go in. We could hear the auditions through the door.
Sometimes 5-6 people would be hanging out with me waiting to go in. I met some cool people, some of whom gave me their CD. I told them that I didn't have anything to do with the selections, but they gave them to me anyway. Some were nervous, some kept to themselves, and I felt like a couple were old friends the way we got along. I would just try to relax everyone by telling then exactly what was going to happen when they got in the room.
One guy (who looked like Wolverine) didn't make the cut in the Memphis audition and drove all the way here for another try. I was in the bathroom when he came in after his audition to relieve himself. I hate when people talk to me when I'm "going" in public bathrooms, so I left him alone; despite the friendship we formed out in the hall before he sang. I was washing my hands and I could feel him looking at me from the urinal. I looked over at him, and with a sigh of relief he said "I made it." I was really happy for him, but I didn't shake his hand.
My point is, all of these people could really sing, and I didn't recognize any of them on the show when it aired. None of the tremendous talent I heard who made it to the next round of auditions made it to TV. Either The Voice has incredible standards, or American Idol isn't taking the cream of the crop from their auditions.
P.S.
A lot of the singers I met doing The Voice had also auditioned for American Idol, and they said The Voice auditions were run a lot better. They said that auditioning for AI they were cut off after singing for just a few seconds. The Voice (callbacks) let them sing at least a full song, and a lot of times 2-3 full songs.
P.P.S.
Does Ryan Seacrest still end the show with "Seacrest out?"